Trent throws a mandatory staff Halloween Party and Cristela and Josh take on the challenge of making it a great one. It results in the office staff bringing out their inner selves with their costumes. Meanwhile Natalia builds an altar for the Day of the Dead, frustrated that her family chose Halloween instead. When they return from Trick or Treating, they're surprised to find Natalia with an audience of wide-eyed neighborhood children, enthralled with her stories.