Caitlin saves Annie before Olivia could find her in Caitlin's room. When Annie realizes that Caitlin is coming back to her room, she returns the tape back in Caitlin's jewelry box. Caitlin asks Annie if she has some other motives which she can get by helping her. Annie tells her that she wants to get good with Gregory, and the two girls make a deal to help each other. Caitlin will do anything she can to help her with Gregory, if Annie can get her a baby.