Jill vents her frustration to Esther about the music box. Esther puts the pieces together about who it is from. Jack warns Kyle not to underestimate Victor and tells him to look into Bonaventure Industries. Neil tells Avery to try to keep Leslie's schedule clear because he has a Christmas surprise for her. Avery figures out that Neil plans on proposing to Leslie! Meanwhile, Lauren blames Leslie for defending Carmine and having the drug dealing charges dropped. Paul calls Michael and asks him to collect his personal effects from the night he was arrested. Paul tells Christine that he finally found the first piece of evidence that could lead them to Carmine's real killer. Later, Fen withdraws his confession. Noah brings a Christmas tree to Sharon's and they decorate it with Nick and Faith. Later, Noah meets up with Courtney and she receives another text from Zach.